Amouage Reflection Man vs Gucci Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Amouage Reflection Man vs Gucci Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme: how alike they are
Amouage Reflection Man vs Gucci Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme: 72% of 1,358 people say the two smell alike. Both lean floral, sweet and powdery. 75% of 1,803 people say Reflection Man lasts a long time, against 90% of 391 for Guilty Elixir.
Quick facts
- Smell alike: 72% of 1,358 people say yes.
- Lasts a long time: 75% of 1,803 people for Reflection Man, 90% of 391 for Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme.
- Projects strongly: 60% of 1,722 people for Reflection Man, 85% of 387 for Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme.
- Per 100 ml: $395 for Reflection Man, $161 for Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme.
- Launched: Reflection Man in 2006, Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme in 2023.
Compared
| Compared | Amouage Reflection Man | Gucci Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme |
|---|---|---|
| Scent family | Floral | Floral |
| Top accords | floral, fresh, sweet and powdery | floral, sweet, spicy and powdery |
| Lasts | 75% long (1,803) | 90% long (391) |
| Projects | 60% strong (1,722) | 85% strong (387) |
| Listed price | $395 (100 ml) | $96.60 (60 ml) |
| Price per 100 ml | $395 | $161 |
| Listed seasons | spring, summer and fall | spring, fall and winter |
| People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) | 1,073 | 32 |
In the Lasts and Projects cells, "75% long (1,803)" means that of the 1,803 people who described it, 75% say it lasts a long time.
What do Reflection Man and Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme share?
They share three of the accords in the table: floral, sweet and powdery. In the notes, they meet on patchouli. Reflection Man reads as woody garden after rain with a whisper of jasmine; Guilty Elixir reads as warm orange blossom cream with nutmeg dust.
What sets Reflection Man and Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme apart?
Only Reflection Man lists bitter orange leaf, red pepper and rosemary; only Guilty Elixir lists orange blossom absolute, nutmeg and pimento. In the accords, Reflection Man adds fresh while Guilty Elixir adds spicy. A larger share of people say Guilty Elixir projects strongly (85% of 387 against 60% of 1,722).
Price, like for like
Guilty Elixir costs less per ml: $161 per 100 ml against $395. Per ml, Reflection Man costs 2.5 times as much.
Reflection Man or Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme: which fragrance should you choose?
These picks follow the votes, wear shares and prices above.
- Choose Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme if you want it to last: 90% of 391 people say it lasts a long time, against 75% for Reflection Man.
- Choose Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme if you want more projection: 85% of 387 people say it projects strongly, against 60%.
- Choose Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme if price per ml matters: $161 per 100 ml, against $395 for Reflection Man.
Common questions
Quick answers to what people ask about this pair, using the numbers above.
Are Reflection Man and Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme the same scent?
72% of 1,358 people say they smell alike, so many find them similar, not the same.
Does one last longer than the other?
A larger share of people say Guilty Elixir lasts a long time: 90% of 391, against 75% of 1,803 for the other.
Which one is listed for summer?
Reflection Man. It is listed for spring, summer and fall; Guilty Elixir is listed for spring, fall and winter.
Which of the two do more people talk about?
Reflection Man: 1,073 people discuss it in posts, against 32 for the other.
What do the two have in common?
They share three accords (floral, sweet and powdery) and one listed note (patchouli).
Are they in the same scent family?
Yes, both are filed under Floral.
What the percentages mean
1,358 people voted on this pair, and 72% said the two smell alike. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
In short: 72% of 1,358 people say they smell alike, and Guilty Elixir costs less per ml.
See also: Amouage Reflection Man · Gucci Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme · Alternatives to Reflection Man · Alternatives to Guilty Elixir de Parfum Pour Homme · More from Amouage · More from Gucci. Still torn? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you already love, and it will point you to the ones worth sampling.