Bvlgari Black vs Van Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris: How Alike Are They?
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Bvlgari Black vs Van Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris: how alike they are
In the Bvlgari Black vs Van Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris vote, 72% of 1,013 people say the two smell alike. Bvlgari Black is filed under Woody and Midnight in Paris under Warm & Amber. Still, both lean leathery, sweet and spicy. Their listed notes overlap on bergamot, leather and amber.
Key facts
- Smell alike: 72% of 1,013 people say yes.
- Lasts a long time: 35% of 109 people for Bvlgari Black, 40% of 129 for Midnight in Paris.
- Per 100 ml: $85.98 for Bvlgari Black, $39.67 for Midnight in Paris.
- Launched: Bvlgari Black in 1998, Midnight in Paris in 2010.
- Labels: unisex for Bvlgari Black, men's for Midnight in Paris.
Side by side
| Compared | Bvlgari Black | Van Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris |
|---|---|---|
| Scent family | Woody | Warm & Amber |
| Top accords | leathery, sweet, smoky and spicy | powdery, sweet, spicy and leathery |
| Lasts | 45% moderate · 35% long (109) | 40% long · 40% moderate (129) |
| Projects | 45% close to skin · 30% moderate (88) | 40% strong · 30% moderate (111) |
| Listed price | $85.98 (100 ml) | $49.59 (125 ml) |
| Price per 100 ml | $85.98 | $39.67 |
| Listed seasons | spring, fall and winter | spring, fall and winter |
| People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) | 204 | 65 |
In the Lasts and Projects cells, "45% moderate (109)" means that of the 109 people who described it, 45% say it lasts a moderate time.
What do Bvlgari Black and Midnight in Paris have in common?
They share three of the accords in the table: leathery, sweet and spicy. Their listed notes overlap on bergamot, leather and amber. In a line each: Bvlgari Black is smoky leather jacket, green tea and cedar warmth; Midnight in Paris is powdery leather gloves, sweet smoky city air.
What is the difference between Bvlgari Black and Midnight in Paris?
Bvlgari Black adds green tea, jasmine and cedarwood, and Midnight in Paris adds lemon, rosemary and lily of the valley. In the accords, Bvlgari Black adds smoky while Midnight in Paris adds powdery.
Price, like for like
Midnight in Paris costs less per ml: $39.67 per 100 ml against $85.98. Per ml, Bvlgari Black costs 2.2 times as much.
How do you choose between the Bvlgari Black and Midnight in Paris fragrances?
These picks follow the votes, wear shares and prices above.
- Choose Midnight in Paris if you want it to last: 40% of 129 people say it lasts a long time, against 35% for Bvlgari Black.
- Choose Midnight in Paris if price per ml matters: $39.67 per 100 ml, against $85.98 for Bvlgari Black.
Common questions
The usual questions about these two, answered from the same votes, wear shares and prices.
Is Bvlgari Black the same as Midnight in Paris?
Not the same, but similar for many people: 72% of 1,013 voters say they smell alike.
Which of the two has better longevity?
They are close, both about 40%: 35% of 109 people say Bvlgari Black lasts a long time, and 40% of 129 say the same of Midnight in Paris.
Which of the two do more people talk about?
Bvlgari Black: 204 people discuss it in posts, against 65 for the other.
What do the two have in common?
They share three accords (leathery, sweet and spicy) and three listed notes (bergamot, leather and amber).
Are they in the same scent family?
No. Bvlgari Black is filed under Woody, Midnight in Paris under Warm & Amber.
How to read these numbers
The 72% figure comes from people voting on whether these two smell alike; 1,013 voted. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
In short: 72% of 1,013 people say they smell alike, and Midnight in Paris costs less per ml.
Where to go from here: Bvlgari Black · Van Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris · More from Bvlgari · More from Van Cleef & Arpels · Woody perfumes. Want a personal read? Give Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you wear, and it will suggest where to go from here.