Bottles of Dossier Floral Marshmallow, Alexandria Fragrances Fructus Virginis, Oakcha Sweet Addict, Dossier Ambery Saffron and Oakcha Desert Glass

Dossier vs Alexandria Fragrances vs Oakcha: Which Smell-Alike House Matches Best?

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Scendira · Three smell-alike houses, compared on votes

Which smell-alike house matches best: Dossier, Alexandria Fragrances or Oakcha?

By median agreement, Dossier is highest at 89% of voters, then Oakcha (85%) and Alexandria Fragrances (69%). Most Dossier and Oakcha pairs have under 100 voters, so treat them as early reads. The price gap is 2.9× to 3.8× per ml.

Dossier, Alexandria Fragrances and Oakcha all sell perfumes built to remind you of pricier ones. They are not the same kind of house, and the fairest way to compare them is by votes, not marketing: for each pair, the share of people who voted that the two perfumes smell alike.

How we compared the houses

To be included, a house needs at least 5 pairs where both perfumes are live and where 60% or more of at least 30 voters say they smell alike. All 15 houses we checked pass. Dossier has 21 such pairs, Oakcha 13 and Alexandria Fragrances 62. The votes come from people who voted on whether the two smell alike; they are not claims by the houses.

The three houses side by side

Dossier Alexandria Fragrances Oakcha
Pairs (both perfumes live) 21 62 13
Its perfumes in those pairs 18 57 12
Median share saying alike 89% 69% 85%
Pairs with under 100 voters (early reads) 19 44 13
Price gap to the paired perfume (median, per ml) 3.8× 2.9× 3.8×
Extra cost per ml of the paired perfume (median) $1.79 $2.26 $2.27

Read the early-read row first. Nearly all of Dossier's pairs (19 of 21) and every one of Oakcha's (13 of 13) rest on fewer than 100 voters, so their high medians (89% and 85%) are early signals, not settled verdicts. Alexandria Fragrances has the lowest median of the three (69%), with 44 of 62 pairs still early.

What each house is being compared to

Dossier. The pair with the most voters is Dossier Floral Marshmallow against By Kilian Love Don't Be Shy: 86% of 481 voters say alike, at $59 for 100 ml against $250 for 50 ml. Dossier Ambery Saffron against Baccarat Rouge 540 is 97% of 87 voters, at $40.29 for 50 ml against $284.99 for 70 ml.

Alexandria Fragrances. Its pairs have more voters but lower agreement: Fructus Virginis against Tom Ford Lost Cherry is 71% of 346, and Zion against Roja Elysium Pour Homme Parfum Cologne is 67% of 335. Several others sit just over the 60% line.

Oakcha. Oakcha Sweet Addict against Love Don't Be Shy is 93% of 68 voters, and Oakcha Desert Glass against Byredo Mojave Ghost is 85% of 60.

The other 12 houses, ranked by agreement

Of all 15 houses, Dossier ranks first (89%), Oakcha ties for second (85%) with Fragrance World and Maison Alhambra, and Alexandria Fragrances ranks last (69%). Here are the other 12.

House Pairs (both perfumes live) Pairs with under 100 voters Median share saying alike Price gap (median, per ml)
Fragrance World 188 155 85% 4.7×
Maison Alhambra 383 272 85% 4.5×
Khadlaj 80 61 84% 1.3×
Paris Corner 198 143 83% 1.7×
French Avenue 171 102 82% 1.7×
Al Haramain 166 98 79% 1.2×
Lattafa 487 264 78% 2.2×
Afnan 173 97 77% 1.5×
Armaf 291 170 77% 2.2×
Zara 171 89 76% 1.9×
Rasasi 163 90 75% 1.4×
The Dua Brand 36 32 74% 2.3×

Big houses on the list, such as Lattafa, Armaf and Afnan, have hundreds of pairs and medians of 77% to 78%. Maison Alhambra and Fragrance World have the widest price gap: the paired perfume costs a median 4.5× and 4.7× as much per ml. Al Haramain has the narrowest, at 1.2×. Our price study of 1,873 pairs looks at that gap across the whole catalog.

So which house matches best?

On agreement alone, Dossier has the highest median of the three (and of all 15), but it rests mostly on early reads. Oakcha is in the same position. Alexandria Fragrances has the most votes behind its lower number, so its 69% is the steadier figure. If you want the perfume you are curious about rather than the house, ask Dira, Your Fragrance Finder or take the perfume quiz, and read the pair's page before you buy.

How we counted

Each pair is two live perfumes that 60%+ of at least 30 voters say smell alike; a house is judged on its median and its count of early reads (under 100 voters). Prices are listed prices per ml, recorded sources only. Counts read 15 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Which smell-alike house do people say matches best?

By median agreement, Dossier is highest at 89% of voters, then Oakcha at 85%, but nearly all of their pairs have fewer than 100 voters. Alexandria Fragrances is lower at 69% with more votes behind it.

How is this measured?

For each pair, the share of people who voted that the two perfumes smell alike. A pair counts if 60% or more of at least 30 voters agree.

Are Dossier, Alexandria Fragrances and Oakcha cheaper than the originals?

On the median, yes: the paired perfume costs 3.8× as much per ml as Dossier, 2.9× as Alexandria Fragrances and 3.8× as Oakcha.

Does a high percentage mean the perfumes are identical?

No. It means most voters said they smell alike. Notes, wear and projection can still differ, so read both pages.

Which houses did you compare?

Fifteen: Lattafa, Armaf, Afnan, Maison Alhambra, Al Haramain, Zara, Dossier, Alexandria Fragrances, French Avenue, Fragrance World, Paris Corner, Rasasi, Oakcha, The Dua Brand and Khadlaj.

Back to blog