Mancera Roses Vanille vs Montale Roses Musk: How Alike Are They?
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Mancera Roses Vanille vs Montale Roses Musk: how alike they are
On Mancera Roses Vanille vs Montale Roses Musk, 64% of 1,092 people say the two smell alike. Both lean sweet and floral. On wear they are close, both about 70%: 75% of 146 people say Roses Vanille lasts a long time, and 70% of 175 say the same of Roses Musk.
Quick facts
- Smell alike: 64% of 1,092 people say yes.
- Lasts a long time: 75% of 146 people for Roses Vanille, 70% of 175 for Roses Musk.
- Projects strongly: 70% of 128 people for Roses Vanille, 70% of 158 for Roses Musk.
- Per 100 ml: $225 for Roses Vanille, $190 for Roses Musk.
- Launched: Roses Vanille in 2011, Roses Musk in 2009.
Compared
| Compared | Mancera Roses Vanille | Montale Roses Musk |
|---|---|---|
| Scent family | Floral | Floral |
| Top accords | sweet, floral, gourmand and warm & amber | floral, sweet, fresh and powdery |
| Lasts | 75% long (146) | 70% long (175) |
| Projects | 70% strong (128) | 70% strong (158) |
| Listed price | $135 (60 ml) | $190 (100 ml) |
| Price per 100 ml | $225 | $190 |
| Listed seasons | spring, fall and winter | spring, summer, fall and winter |
| People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) | 563 | 144 |
In the Lasts and Projects cells, "75% long (146)" means that of the 146 people who described it, 75% say it lasts a long time.
What do Roses Vanille and Roses Musk have in common?
They share two of the accords in the table: sweet and floral. Both list white musk. Roses Vanille reads as creamy rose candy with vanilla powder; Roses Musk reads as fresh rose petals wrapped in soft powdery musk.
What sets Roses Vanille and Roses Musk apart?
Notes you get in one but not the other: Calabrian lemon, vanilla and cedarwood in Roses Vanille, jasmine in Roses Musk. In the accords, Roses Vanille adds gourmand and warm & amber while Roses Musk adds fresh and powdery.
Price, like for like
Roses Musk costs less per ml: $190 per 100 ml against $225.
Which fragrance should you pick, Roses Vanille or Roses Musk?
A quick way to choose, using only this page's counts and prices.
- Choose Roses Vanille if you want it to last: 75% of 146 people say it lasts a long time, against 70% for Roses Musk.
- Choose Roses Musk if price per ml matters: $190 per 100 ml, against $225 for Roses Vanille.
Common questions
Common questions about this pair, each answered from this page's own data.
Do Roses Vanille and Roses Musk smell the same?
Not the same, but similar for many people: 64% of 1,092 voters say they smell alike.
Which one lasts longer?
They are close, both about 70%: 75% of 146 people say Roses Vanille lasts a long time, and 70% of 175 say the same of Roses Musk.
Which one is listed for summer?
Roses Musk. It is listed for spring, summer, fall and winter; Roses Vanille is listed for spring, fall and winter.
Which of the two do more people talk about?
Roses Vanille: 563 people discuss it in posts, against 144 for the other.
What do the two have in common?
They share two accords (sweet and floral) and one listed note (white musk).
Are they in the same scent family?
Yes, both are filed under Floral.
How we count this
1,092 people voted on this pair, and 64% said the two smell alike. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
In short: 64% of 1,092 people say they smell alike, and Roses Musk costs less per ml.
See also: Mancera Roses Vanille · Montale Roses Musk · Alternatives to Roses Vanille · More from Mancera · More from Montale. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will suggest what to try next.