Perfumes Like By Kilian Black Phantom: 5 Alternatives, Closest First
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Perfumes like By Kilian Black Phantom, closest first
When people compare perfumes like By Kilian Black Phantom on pairs with 100 or more voters, the best-voted alternative is French Avenue Spectre Wraith, and 88% of 336 people say the two smell alike. The list has three well-voted alternatives and two early reads with 30 to 99 voters.
What kind of fragrance is By Kilian Black Phantom, and who is it for?
By Kilian Black Phantom, in a line: rum-soaked dark chocolate, coffee and vanilla. By its listed notes, it opens on rum; the heart is dark chocolate, coffee, almond and heliotrope; it dries down to caramel, sugar cane, sandalwood and vanilla. The main accords are sweet, warm spicy, caramel, chocolate, coffee and rum, which puts it with the gourmand perfumes. Of the 38 people who described how long it lasts, 65% say it lasts a long time. 17 people have described how far it projects so far. In reviews and threads, 604 people discuss it. It came out in 2017 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in fall and winter. In posts about it, 64 people bring up winter or cold weather, 40 bring up fall and 39 bring up summer or hot weather. See the full notes on the By Kilian Black Phantom page.
What makes a good Black Phantom alternative
Black Phantom is built on sweet, warm spicy and caramel accords, with rum up top and caramel and sugar cane in the drydown. In the table, 2 of the 3 alternatives share at least two of those accords. The accord they share most often is sweet, in 3 of the 3.
Side by side: the three perfumes people match to it
| Perfume | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Shared accords | Lasts | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| French Avenue Spectre Wraith | 88% (336) | sweet and warm spicy | 65% long (53) | Warm & Amber | $67, 80 ml ($83.75 per 100 ml) |
| Faviol Seferi Insomnia | 79% (374) | sweet | 80% long (41) | Gourmand | $74.52, 50 ml ($149.04 per 100 ml) |
| Alexandria Fragrances Dark Knight | 63% (283) | sweet, warm spicy and caramel | 15 people | Gourmand | $109.99, 100 ml |
In the Lasts column, "65% long (53)" means that of the 53 people who described it, 65% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.
Listed prices shift over time; an 'about' price is an estimate.
What each alternative shares and where it differs
From Spectre Wraith (88% alike) down to Dark Knight (63%), what each one changes.
French Avenue Spectre Wraith
It alone lists spices in the opening. It sits on the warm and amber side rather than the gourmand one. Still, both keep rum in the opening, coffee in the heart and sugar cane in the drydown.
Faviol Seferi Insomnia
On wear, 80% of 41 people say it lasts a long time, against 65% of 38 for Black Phantom. Both list rum in the opening, coffee in the heart and sandalwood in the drydown. In the drydown, it lists patchouli rather than sugar cane.
Alexandria Fragrances Dark Knight
63% of 283 voters say the two smell alike. Both have rum in the opening.
Early reads (30 to 99 voters)
These have 30 to 99 voters each, so the votes are still small.
| Early read | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emper Phantom My Hero | 91% (88) | Warm & Amber | $18, 100 ml |
| Black Phantom Anniversary Edition (same house) | 81% (43) | Gourmand | about $231, size not listed |
How we count this
We show two numbers per perfume: the share of voters who said it smells alike, and how many people voted. The cut-off is 60% with at least 30 votes; fewer than 100 votes counts as an early read. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
Questions and answers
Common questions about these alternatives, each answered from this page's own numbers.
What smells closest to Black Phantom?
French Avenue Spectre Wraith. 88% of the 336 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the top score among pairs with 100+ voters. Emper Phantom My Hero scores higher, 91% of 88, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.
Which Black Phantom alternative costs least per ml?
Emper Phantom My Hero, at $18 for 100 ml. 91% of 88 people say it smells alike. It is an early read (under 100 voters).
Which alternative has the highest share saying it lasts a long time?
Faviol Seferi Insomnia: 80% of the 41 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the two alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.
How many alternatives are listed here?
Three have 100 or more voters and two more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 5 in all. A match needs 60% or more of its voters saying it smells alike to be listed.
Which alternative has the most votes?
Faviol Seferi Insomnia: 374 people voted, and 79% of them say it smells alike.
In short: 88% of 336 people say Spectre Wraith smells like Black Phantom.
Where next: By Kilian Black Phantom · More from By Kilian · By Kilian perfumes ranked by people · Browse gourmand perfumes · Almond perfumes. Give Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will suggest which of these to try first.