Perfumes Like Creed Carmina: 5 Matches People Voted On
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Perfumes like Creed Carmina, by share of votes
Perfumes like Creed Carmina: the closest early read is Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby, and 83% of 36 people say the two smell alike, though no pair has reached 100 voters yet, so treat every match here as a lead. Avant Ruby costs less per ml: $21.99 per 100 ml against $513.32. The five early reads are below, closest first.
What is the Creed Carmina fragrance like, and who wears it?
Scendira describes Creed Carmina as rosy floral with tart cherry sparkle. By its listed notes, it opens on black cherry, pink pepper and saffron; the heart is may rose, peony, cashmere wood and violet; it dries down to musk, amber, frankincense and myrrh. The main accords are floral, fruity, sweet, spicy and woody, in the floral family. Of the 104 people who described how long it lasts, 70% say it lasts a long time. Of the 87 people who described how far it projects, 55% say it projects strongly. It lists at $384.99 (75 ml), which is $513.32 per 100 ml. It came out in 2023 and carries a women's label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring, fall and winter. See the full notes on the Creed Carmina page.
What makes a good Carmina alternative
Carmina is built on floral, fruity and sweet accords, with black cherry and pink pepper up top and musk and amber in the drydown. In the table, 1 of the 5 alternatives share at least two of those accords, and 2 share none of them. The accord they share most often is floral, in 3 of the 5.
Early reads at a glance (under 100 voters)
| Perfume | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Shared accords | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby | 83% (36, early read) | floral and fruity | Floral | $21.99, 100 ml |
| Hamidi Cleopatra | 78% (45, early read) | none in common | Warm & Amber | $27.99, 100 ml |
| Zimaya Charisma Pour Femme | 78% (32, early read) | floral | Floral | $25.86, 100 ml |
| Fragrance World Venti Carisma | 74% (35, early read) | none in common | Floral / Rose | about $25, size not listed |
| Oakcha Rosalina | 68% (41, early read) | floral | Floral / Rose | $39.95, 50 ml ($79.90 per 100 ml) |
All four with a bottle size on record cost less per ml than Carmina. Prices move often, and an 'about' price is only an estimate.
What each alternative shares and where it differs
Five write-ups, Avant Ruby first, each naming what that perfume adds or drops.
Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby
The clearest note gap is in the drydown: Ambroxan rather than amber. Both list black cherry, pink pepper and saffron in the opening.
Hamidi Cleopatra
It leans warm and amber rather than floral. In the drydown, expect Ambroxan in place of amber. Underneath, both have black cherry, pink pepper and saffron in the opening.
Zimaya Charisma Pour Femme
On price, it costs about 5% of Carmina's price per ml ($25.86 against $513.32 per 100 ml). They meet on black cherry, pink pepper and saffron in the opening. In the drydown, it lists Ambroxan rather than myrrh.
Fragrance World Venti Carisma
74% of 35 voters say the two smell alike. The overlap is black cherry, pink pepper and saffron in the opening.
Oakcha Rosalina
The drydown is where it parts ways: Ambroxan instead of amber. The overlap is black cherry, pink pepper and saffron in the opening.
How we count this
We show two numbers per perfume: the share of voters who said it smells alike, and how many people voted. The cut-off is 60% with at least 30 votes; fewer than 100 votes counts as an early read. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
Questions and answers
Quick answers to what people ask about these alternatives, using the votes and prices above.
What smells closest to Carmina?
Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby. 83% of the 36 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike (an early read: no pair has 100 voters yet).
Which perfume like Carmina is lowest per 100 ml?
Maison Alhambra Avant Ruby, at $21.99 for 100 ml. 83% of 36 people say it smells alike.
How many perfumes smell like Carmina?
Five so far, all early reads with 30 to 99 voters. A match needs 60% or more of its voters saying it smells alike to be listed.
Which alternative has the most votes?
Hamidi Cleopatra: 45 people voted, and 78% of them say it smells alike. That is an early read.
Do the alternatives share its scent family?
Carmina sits in the floral family. Four of the five in the table share it: Avant Ruby, Charisma Pour Femme, Venti Carisma and Rosalina.
In short: 83% of 36 people say Avant Ruby smells like Carmina, and it costs less per ml.
Related pages: Creed Carmina · More from Creed · The most-discussed Creed perfumes · Browse floral perfumes · Pink pepper perfumes. Still torn? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you already love, and it will narrow this list to the ones worth sampling.