Perfumes Like Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace: 9 Matches People Voted On
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Perfumes like Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace, ranked by votes
Looking for perfumes like Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace? Among pairs with 100 or more voters, the closest match is Fragrance World Ace, and 86% of 124 people say the two smell alike. The list has eight well-voted alternatives and six early reads with 30 to 99 voters.
Quick facts
- Closest match: Fragrance World Ace, which 86% of 124 people say smells alike.
- 8 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
- Highest share saying it lasts a long time: Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud, 80% of 386 people.
- The original itself: 65% of 1,173 people say it lasts a long time.
What is Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace like, and who might it suit?
Scendira sums up Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace as smoky chestnuts and clove warmth by a fire. By its listed notes, it opens on clove, pink pepper and orange blossom absolute; the heart is guaiac wood, chestnut and cade juniper; it dries down to vanilla, Cashmeran and peru balsam. The main accords are smoky, sweet, woody, spicy, gourmand and resinous, which puts it with the woody perfumes. Of the 1,173 people who described how long it lasts, 65% say it lasts a long time. Of the 1,120 people who described how far it projects, 50% say it projects strongly. It came out in 2015 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in fall and winter. In posts about it, 647 people bring up winter or cold weather, 424 bring up fall and 284 bring up summer or hot weather. See the full notes on the Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace page.
All 8 alternatives with 100+ voters, side by side
| Perfume | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Shared accords | Lasts | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fragrance World Ace | 86% (124) | woody and spicy | 10 people | Gourmand | about $24, size not listed |
| Paris Corner Factory Edition: Camp Fire | 82% (122) | woody | no reports yet | Floral | about $33, size not listed |
| Giardino Benessere Bianco Laos | 80% (205) | smoky, sweet and spicy | 70% long (43) | Woody / Smoky | $135, 100 ml |
| Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud | 76% (1,706) | smoky, sweet and woody | 80% long (386) | Warm & Amber | $19.74, 100 ml |
| Dior Bois Talisman | 75% (382) | smoky, sweet and woody | 55% long (85) | Woody | $231, 50 ml ($462 per 100 ml) |
| Phlur Vanilla Smoke (body mist) | 73% (135) | smoky, sweet and woody | 45% long · 30% moderate (30) | Woody / Smoky | $28, 236 ml ($11.86 per 100 ml) |
| Scents of Wood Praline in Maple | 63% (133) | sweet, woody and spicy | 70% long (33) | Woody | $240, 75 ml ($320 per 100 ml) |
| Commodity Velvet | 62% (452) | smoky, sweet and spicy | 45% long · 30% short (32) | Woody / Smoky | about $22, size not listed |
In the Lasts column, "70% long (43)" means that of the 43 people who described it, 70% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.
Prices change often; an 'about' price is an estimate.
Which of these fragrances should you choose?
These picks follow the numbers, so read them as starting points, not verdicts.
- Choose Fragrance World Ace if you want the closest scent: 86% of 124 people say it smells alike.
- Choose Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud if price and wear both matter: $19.74 per 100 ml is the lowest among the alternatives with 100+ voters, and 80% of 386 people say it lasts a long time, the highest share here.
- Choose Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud if you want more projection: 70% of 362 people say it projects strongly, the highest share here.
- Look at Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud for winter wear: 135 people, 27% of those talking about it, mention winter or cold weather with it.
- Skip Paris Corner Factory Edition: Camp Fire if you want to stay in the woody family: it is filed under floral.
What each alternative shares and where it differs
What Fragrance World Ace, Commodity Velvet and the rest change, in table order.
Fragrance World Ace
It leans gourmand rather than woody. Both list pink pepper and orange blossom absolute in the opening and chestnut in the heart.
Paris Corner Factory Edition: Camp Fire
It leans floral rather than woody. Underneath, both have pink pepper and orange blossom absolute in the opening and chestnut in the heart.
Giardino Benessere Bianco Laos
It alone lists birch and Laotian oud in the drydown. They meet on pink pepper in the opening and peru balsam in the drydown.
Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud
On wear, 80% of 386 people say it lasts a long time, against 65% of 1,173 for By the Fireplace. The overlap is vanilla in the drydown. It has the most voters of any pair here (1,706). In the opening, expect nutmeg and saffron in place of clove and pink pepper. From a review: "Smells like a softer By the Fireplace!" Read the full comparison.
Dior Bois Talisman
The heart is where it parts ways: sugar instead of guaiac wood and chestnut. Both lean smoky, sweet and woody.
Phlur Vanilla Smoke
45% of 30 people say it lasts a long time, against 65% of 1,173 for By the Fireplace. Both have pink pepper in the opening and peru balsam in the drydown. It adds birch and bergamot in the opening. One reviewer puts it this way: "This smells like a lighter, sweeter by the fireplace."
Scents of Wood Praline in Maple
Its own addition is olibanum in the opening. They meet on clove and pink pepper in the opening.
Commodity Velvet
In the heart, rose and heliotrope take the place of guaiac wood and chestnut. The overlap is clove in the opening.
Early reads, closest first
Fewer than 100 people have voted on these pairs, so read them as leads.
| Early read | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|
| F1 Parfums Overtake 320 Eau de Toilette | 87% (30) | Warm & Amber | $77.99, 75 ml ($103.99 per 100 ml) |
Five more early reads, with fewer votes and under 86% alike, left out of the table.
Where the numbers come from
Voters are the people who rated each pair; % alike is the part of them who said the two smell alike. Pairs need 60%+ agreement and 30+ votes to appear here, with under-100-vote pairs marked as early reads. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
Questions and answers
Common questions about these alternatives, each answered from this page's own numbers.
What smells closest to By the Fireplace?
Fragrance World Ace. 86% of the 124 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the closest of the pairs with 100+ voters. F1 Parfums Overtake 320 Eau de Toilette scores higher, 87% of 30, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.
Which perfume like By the Fireplace is lowest per 100 ml?
Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud, at $19.74 for 100 ml. 76% of 1,706 people say it smells alike. A body mist on this page lists lower per 100 ml, but body mists are not compared with spray bottles on price.
Which alternative has the highest share saying it lasts a long time?
Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud: 80% of the 386 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the six alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.
How many alternatives do people back?
Eight have 100 or more voters and six more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 14 in all. A pair is listed only when 60% or more of its voters say it smells alike.
Which alternative has the most votes?
Lattafa Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud: 1,706 people voted, and 76% of them say it smells alike.
Do the alternatives share its scent family?
By the Fireplace sits in the woody family. Five of the eight in the table share it: Bianco Laos, Bois Talisman, Vanilla Smoke, Praline in Maple and Commodity Velvet.
In short: 86% of 124 people say Fragrance World Ace smells like By the Fireplace.
See also: Maison Martin Margiela By the Fireplace · More from Maison Martin Margiela · Maison Martin Margiela perfumes ranked by people · By the Fireplace vs Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud · Browse woody perfumes · Clove perfumes. Share two perfumes you love with Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, and it will pick the ones on this list that fit you.