Perfumes Like Mancera Red Tobacco: 13 Alternatives, Closest First
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Perfumes like Mancera Red Tobacco, closest first
Looking for perfumes like Mancera Red Tobacco? The closest match is Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac, and 87% of 129 people say the two smell alike. Seven alternatives clear 100 voters, and six more are early reads. The table gives every one's scent family, longevity and listed price.
Key facts
- Closest match: Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac, which 87% of 129 people say smells alike.
- 7 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
- Highest share saying it lasts a long time: Parfums de Marly Carlisle, 90% of 694 people.
- The original itself: 95% of 740 people say it lasts a long time.
What is Mancera Red Tobacco like, and who might it suit?
Mancera Red Tobacco in brief: smoky incense, cinnamon, oud, tobacco leaves. By its listed notes, it opens on cinnamon, green apple, incense and Nepalese oud; the heart is patchouli and jasmine; it dries down to tobacco, vanilla, guaiac wood and woody notes. The main accords are spicy, sweet, woody, smoky, warm & amber and fruity, in the warm and amber family. Of the 740 people who described how long it lasts, 95% say it lasts a long time. Of the 767 people who described how far it projects, 95% say it projects strongly. It came out in 2017 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in fall and winter. In posts about it, 186 people bring up winter or cold weather, 100 bring up summer or hot weather and 77 bring up fall. See the full notes on the Mancera Red Tobacco page.
The seven closest matches, in one table
| Perfume | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Shared accords | Lasts | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac | 87% (129) | spicy and sweet | 85% long (36) | Warm & Amber | about $22, size not listed |
| Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco | 77% (446) | spicy and sweet | 26 people | Warm & Amber | about $340, size not listed |
| Paris Corner Charuto Mysterious Tobacco | 77% (117) | sweet and woody | 11 people | Fresh | about $26, size not listed |
| Argos Triumph Of Bacchus | 71% (632) | spicy, sweet and woody | 85% long (460) | Gourmand | $325, 100 ml |
| Tiziana Terenzi Arrakis | 70% (197) | spicy, sweet and woody | 14 people | Woody | $250.58, 100 ml |
| Parfums de Marly Carlisle | 69% (1,598) | spicy, sweet and woody | 90% long (694) | Warm & Amber | about $460, size not listed |
| Alexandria Fragrances Hafez 1984 | 65% (197) | spicy and sweet | 85% long (37) | Warm & Amber | $46.99, 30 ml ($156.63 per 100 ml) |
In the Lasts column, "85% long (36)" means that of the 36 people who described it, 85% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.
Prices change often; an 'about' price is an estimate.
How do you choose among these fragrances?
A quick way to choose, using counts and prices rather than opinion.
- Choose Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac if you want the closest scent: 87% of 129 people say it smells alike.
- Choose Alexandria Fragrances Hafez 1984 if price matters most: $156.63 per 100 ml is the lowest among the alternatives with 100+ voters.
- Choose Parfums de Marly Carlisle if you want it to last: 90% of 694 people say it lasts a long time, the highest share in the table.
- Choose Parfums de Marly Carlisle if you want more projection: 85% of 674 people say it projects strongly, the highest share here.
- Look at Parfums de Marly Carlisle for winter wear: 145 people, 20% of those talking about it, mention winter or cold weather with it.
- Skip Paris Corner Charuto Mysterious Tobacco if you want to stay in the warm and amber family: it is filed under fresh.
The matches, one at a time
Seven write-ups, Exclusif Tabac first, each naming what that perfume adds or drops.
Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac
87% of 129 voters say the two smell alike. Its own addition is artemisia in the opening. Still, both keep patchouli in the heart. Of the 36 people who described how long it lasts, 85% say it lasts a long time.
Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco
The clearest note gap is in the drydown: tonka bean rather than vanilla and guaiac wood. Both list patchouli in the heart and tobacco in the drydown. One reviewer puts it this way: "This smells like a smoother version of Red Tobacco."
Paris Corner Charuto Mysterious Tobacco
It is called alike by 77% of the 117 people who voted on the pair. It leans fresh rather than warm and amber. Underneath, both have patchouli in the heart.
Argos Triumph Of Bacchus
It leans gourmand rather than warm and amber. They meet on green apple in the opening and patchouli and jasmine in the heart. In the opening, it lists white peach and rum rather than cinnamon and incense. From a review: "It reminds me of Mancera Red Tobacco but a lighter version."
Tiziana Terenzi Arrakis
The drydown is where it parts ways: tonka bean instead of vanilla. The overlap is patchouli in the heart. This one reads more woody than warm and amber.
Parfums de Marly Carlisle
With 1,598 voters, this is the most-voted pair here, and 69% of them call it alike. Both list green apple in the opening, patchouli in the heart and vanilla in the drydown. In the opening, expect nutmeg and saffron in place of cinnamon and incense. Full comparison.
Alexandria Fragrances Hafez 1984
In the opening, it swaps Nepalese oud and cinnamon for rum and spices. The common ground is spicy and sweet.
Six early reads (30 to 99 voters each, under 87% alike) are left out of the tables: none scores as high as the closest well-voted match.
What the percentages mean
Each percentage is how many of the people who voted on that pair said the two smell alike. The voter count sits next to it, and anything under 100 voters is flagged as an early read. Nothing below 60% or 30 voters is listed. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
FAQ
Common questions about these alternatives, each answered from this page's own numbers.
Which perfume smells most like Red Tobacco?
Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac. 87% of the 129 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the top score among pairs with 100+ voters.
What is the lowest-priced alternative to Red Tobacco per 100 ml?
Alexandria Fragrances Hafez 1984, at $156.63 per 100 ml ($46.99, 30 ml). 65% of 197 people say it smells alike. Maison Alhambra Exclusif Tabac lists lower, at about $22, but no bottle size is on record, so it can't be put per 100 ml.
Which of these do people most often say lasts a long time?
Parfums de Marly Carlisle: 90% of the 694 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the four alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.
How many perfumes smell like Red Tobacco?
Seven have 100 or more voters and six more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 13 in all. A match needs 60% or more of its voters saying it smells alike to be listed.
Which match has the most voters?
Parfums de Marly Carlisle: 1,598 people voted, and 69% of them say it smells alike.
Which alternatives are in the same scent family?
Red Tobacco sits in the warm and amber family. Four of the seven in the table share it: Exclusif Tabac, Mystery Tobacco, Carlisle and Hafez 1984.
In short: 87% of 129 people say Exclusif Tabac smells like Red Tobacco.
Read more: Mancera Red Tobacco · More from Mancera · The most-discussed Mancera perfumes · Red Tobacco vs Carlisle · Browse amber perfumes · Cinnamon perfumes. Share two perfumes you love with Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, and it will pick the ones on this list that fit you.