Bottles of Parfums de Marly Carlisle, Maison Alhambra Cassius, Borouj Perlador, Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco and Hugo Boss Bottled Absolu

8 Perfumes Like Parfums de Marly Carlisle, Ranked by Voter Agreement

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Perfumes like Parfums de Marly Carlisle that people voted on

When people compare perfumes like Parfums de Marly Carlisle, the closest match is Maison Alhambra Cassius, and 93% of 214 people say the two smell alike. The trade-off is wear: 60% of 45 people say Cassius lasts a long time, against 90% of 694 for Carlisle. Six alternatives clear 100 voters, and two more are early reads.

At a glance

  • Closest match: Maison Alhambra Cassius, which 93% of 214 people say smells alike.
  • 6 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
  • Highest share saying it lasts a long time: Mancera Red Tobacco, 95% of 740 people.
  • The original itself: 90% of 694 people say it lasts a long time.

What does Parfums de Marly Carlisle smell like, and when do people wear it?

Scendira sums up Parfums de Marly Carlisle as spiced fruit compote with creamy vanilla warmth. By its listed notes, it opens on nutmeg, green apple and saffron; the heart is tonka bean, davana, osmanthus and rose; it dries down to vanilla, opoponax, patchouli and sandalwood. The main accords are spicy, sweet, warm & amber, woody, gourmand and fruity, in the warm and amber family. Of the 694 people who described how long it lasts, 90% say it lasts a long time. Of the 674 people who described how far it projects, 85% say it projects strongly. It came out in 2015 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring, fall and winter. In posts about it, 145 people bring up winter or cold weather, 65 bring up fall and 62 bring up summer or hot weather. See the full notes on the Parfums de Marly Carlisle page.

All 6 alternatives with 100+ voters, side by side

Perfume % who say it smells alike (voters) Shared accords Lasts Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Maison Alhambra Cassius 93% (214) spicy and sweet 60% long (45) Warm & Amber $23, 100 ml
Borouj Perlador 88% (204) spicy and sweet 15 people Warm & Amber $69.99, 86 ml ($81.38 per 100 ml)
Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco 75% (265) spicy and sweet 26 people Warm & Amber about $340, size not listed
Hugo Boss Bottled Absolu 72% (801) spicy, sweet and woody 90% long (508) Warm & Amber $143.49, 100 ml
Mancera Red Tobacco 69% (1,598) spicy, sweet and warm & amber 95% long (740) Warm & Amber about $200, size not listed
Mancera Red Tobacco Intense 65% (252) spicy 80% long (96) Woody / Smoky about $120, size not listed

In the Lasts column, "60% long (45)" means that of the 45 people who described it, 60% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.

Prices move often, and an 'about' price is only an estimate.

How do you choose among these fragrances?

A quick way to choose, using counts and prices rather than opinion.

  • Choose Maison Alhambra Cassius if you want the closest scent: 93% of 214 people say it smells alike.
  • Choose Mancera Red Tobacco if you want it to last: 95% of 740 people say it lasts a long time, the highest share in the table.
  • Choose Mancera Red Tobacco if you want more projection: 95% of 767 people say it projects strongly, the highest share here.
  • Look at Hugo Boss Bottled Absolu for winter wear: 172 people, 25% of those talking about it, mention winter or cold weather with it.
  • Skip Mancera Red Tobacco Intense if you want to stay in the warm and amber family: it is filed under woody / smoky.

What each alternative shares and where it differs

What Cassius, Red Tobacco Intense and the rest change, in table order.

Maison Alhambra Cassius

93% of 214 voters say the two smell alike. Both have nutmeg and green apple in the opening and tonka bean in the heart. Of the 45 people who described how long it lasts, 60% say it lasts a long time.

Borouj Perlador

The drydown is where it parts ways: oud and leather instead of vanilla and opoponax. Still, both lean spicy and sweet.

Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco

It is called alike by 75% of the 265 people who voted on the pair. Its own addition is tobacco in the drydown. The common ground is spicy and sweet.

Hugo Boss Bottled Absolu

In the opening, leather and frankincense take the place of green apple and nutmeg. They share spicy, sweet and woody accords.

Mancera Red Tobacco

With 1,598 voters, this is the most-voted pair here, and 69% of them call it alike. Both list nutmeg, green apple and saffron in the opening. In the heart, it lists jasmine rather than tonka bean and davana. One reviewer puts it this way: "Red Tobacco smells like a harsher version of Carlisle." See the two compared.

Mancera Red Tobacco Intense

It leans woody rather than warm and amber. Both have nutmeg and saffron in the opening and vanilla in the drydown. Its list also has tobacco and leather in the heart.

Two early reads (30 to 99 voters each, under 93% alike) are left out of the tables: none scores as high as the closest well-voted match.

How to read these numbers

We show two numbers per perfume: the share of voters who said it smells alike, and how many people voted. The cut-off is 60% with at least 30 votes; fewer than 100 votes counts as an early read. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

Common questions

Quick answers to what people ask about these alternatives, using the votes and prices above.

What is the closest alternative to Carlisle?

Maison Alhambra Cassius. 93% of the 214 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the closest of the pairs with 100+ voters.

Which perfume like Carlisle is lowest per 100 ml?

Maison Alhambra Cassius, at $23 for 100 ml. 93% of 214 people say it smells alike.

Which of these do the most people say lasts a long time?

Mancera Red Tobacco: 95% of the 740 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the four alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.

How many perfumes smell like Carlisle?

Six have 100 or more voters and two more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 8 in all. Only pairs where at least 60% of voters say they smell alike make the list.

Which alternative has the most votes?

Mancera Red Tobacco: 1,598 people voted, and 69% of them say it smells alike.

Do the alternatives share its scent family?

Carlisle sits in the warm and amber family. Five of the six in the table share it: Cassius, Perlador, Mystery Tobacco, Bottled Absolu and Red Tobacco.

In short: 93% of 214 people say Cassius smells like Carlisle, but fewer say it lasts a long time (60% of 45 people against 90% of 694).

Keep exploring: Parfums de Marly Carlisle · More from Parfums de Marly · Parfums de Marly perfumes ranked by people · Carlisle vs Red Tobacco · Browse amber perfumes. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will shortlist the best fits from this list.

Back to blog