Bottles of Phlur Vanilla Skin, Khadlaj Sawaar Vanille Blanc, Bodycology Cozy Fireside S'more, Donna Karan Cashmere & Vanilla Essence and Bath & Body Works Warm Musk

7 Perfumes Like Phlur Vanilla Skin, Ranked by Voter Agreement

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Perfumes like Phlur Vanilla Skin that people voted on

Among perfumes like Phlur Vanilla Skin with 100+ voters on the pair, the closest match is Ariana Grande Plush Vanilla, and 83% of 151 people say the two smell alike. Two pairs have 100+ voters, and five early reads follow in their own table.

Key facts

  • Closest match: Ariana Grande Plush Vanilla, which 83% of 151 people say smells alike.
  • 2 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
  • The original itself: 60% of 154 people say it lasts a long time.

What kind of fragrance is Phlur Vanilla Skin, and who is it for?

Scendira describes Phlur Vanilla Skin as creamy vanilla powder, sweet pink fruit. By its listed notes, it opens on pink pepper, sugar and pink apple; the heart is cashmere wood, jasmine and lily; it dries down to vanilla, benzoin, oud and sandalwood. The main accords are sweet, gourmand, spicy, woody, creamy and powdery, which puts it with the gourmand perfumes. Of the 154 people who described how long it lasts, 60% say it lasts a long time. Of the 73 people who described how far it projects, 45% say it projects strongly and 40% say it stays close to the skin. It came out in 2023 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring, fall and winter. In posts about it, 207 people bring up winter or cold weather, 188 bring up fall and 177 bring up summer or hot weather. See the full notes on the Phlur Vanilla Skin page.

Both well-voted alternatives at a glance

Perfume % who say it smells alike (voters) Shared accords Lasts Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Ariana Grande Plush Vanilla 83% (151) sweet, woody and creamy 29 people Gourmand $77.57, 125 ml ($62.06 per 100 ml)
Victoria's Secret Bare Vanilla 71% (238) sweet, gourmand and creamy 50% short (90) Gourmand about $20, size not listed

In the Lasts column, "50% short (90)" means that of the 90 people who described it, 50% say it fades quickly; under 30 people we show the count only.

Listed prices shift over time; an 'about' price is an estimate.

What each alternative shares and where it differs

Plush Vanilla (83% alike) first, then Bare Vanilla (71%).

Ariana Grande Plush Vanilla

The clearest note gap is in the opening: orange blossom rather than pink pepper and pink apple. Both list sugar in the opening.

Victoria's Secret Bare Vanilla

The opening is where it parts ways: Cashmeran instead of pink pepper and sugar. Underneath, both have vanilla in the drydown.

Early reads (30 to 99 voters)

These have 30 to 99 voters each, so the votes are still small.

Early read % who say it smells alike (voters) Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Khadlaj Sawaar Vanille Blanc 91% (70) Gourmand $55, 100 ml
Bodycology Cozy Fireside S'more 76% (45) Woody / Smoky $11.99, 236 ml ($5.08 per 100 ml)
Donna Karan Cashmere & Vanilla Essence 73% (56) Gourmand / Vanilla about $156, size not listed
Bath & Body Works Warm Musk 73% (33) Gourmand / Vanilla $16.50, 236 ml ($6.99 per 100 ml)
Noyz Only Human 65% (81) Gourmand / Lactonic $85, 50 ml ($170 per 100 ml)

What the percentages mean

Voters are the people who rated each pair; % alike is the part of them who said the two smell alike. Pairs need 60%+ agreement and 30+ votes to appear here, with under-100-vote pairs marked as early reads. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

Common questions

Common questions about these alternatives, each answered from this page's own numbers.

What smells closest to Vanilla Skin?

Ariana Grande Plush Vanilla. 83% of the 151 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the closest of the pairs with 100+ voters. Khadlaj Sawaar Vanille Blanc scores higher, 91% of 70, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.

What is the lowest-priced alternative to Vanilla Skin per 100 ml?

Bodycology Cozy Fireside S'more, at $5.08 per 100 ml ($11.99, 236 ml). 76% of 45 people say it smells alike. It is an early read (under 100 voters).

How many alternatives do people back?

Two have 100 or more voters and five more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 7 in all. Only pairs where at least 60% of voters say they smell alike make the list.

Which alternative has the most votes?

Victoria's Secret Bare Vanilla: 238 people voted, and 71% of them say it smells alike.

Do the alternatives share its scent family?

Vanilla Skin sits in the gourmand family. Both alternatives in the table are in the same family.

In short: 83% of 151 people say Plush Vanilla smells like Vanilla Skin.

Keep reading: Phlur Vanilla Skin · More from Phlur · Phlur perfumes ranked by people · Browse gourmand perfumes · Pink pepper perfumes. Name two perfumes you love for Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, and it will say which of these fits you better.

Back to blog