Bottles of Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium, Zara Gardenia, Dossier Ambery Vanilla, Police To Be Born To Shine Woman and Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Extreme

Perfumes Like Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium: 24 Alternatives, Closest First

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Perfumes like Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium, closest first

When people compare perfumes like Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium on pairs with 100 or more voters, the closest match is Zara Gardenia, and 94% of 417 people say the two smell alike. For the same 90 ml bottle, Gardenia costs less: $42.59 against $88.20. 13 alternatives clear 100 voters, and 11 more are early reads.

Key facts

  • Closest match: Zara Gardenia, which 94% of 417 people say smells alike.
  • 13 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
  • Sharing its gourmand family: 9 of the 13.
  • 3 alternatives tie for the highest share saying they last a long time: 40% of the people describing each.
  • Same house as the original: 6 of the 13 alternatives.

How does Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium smell, and who wears it?

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium, in a line: sweet coffee, creamy vanilla, warm floral. By its listed notes, it opens on orange blossom and pink pepper; the heart is coffee and jasmine; it dries down to vanilla, patchouli and cedarwood. The main accords are sweet, gourmand, floral, warm & amber, spicy and creamy, which puts it with the gourmand perfumes. Of the 787 people who described how long it lasts, 70% say it lasts a long time. Of the 364 people who described how far it projects, 50% say it projects strongly. It lists at $88.20 (90 ml), which is $98 per 100 ml. It came out in 2014 and carries a women's label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in fall and winter. In posts about it, 248 people bring up winter or cold weather, 204 bring up summer or hot weather and 190 bring up fall. See the full notes on the Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium page.

Side by side: the 13 perfumes people match to it

Perfume % who say it smells alike (voters) Shared accords Lasts Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Zara Gardenia 94% (417) floral 23 people Gourmand / Vanilla $42.59, 90 ml ($47.32 per 100 ml)
Dossier Ambery Vanilla 93% (125) sweet, gourmand and spicy 28 people Gourmand $26.12, 50 ml ($52.24 per 100 ml)
Police To Be Born To Shine Woman 88% (130) sweet 10 people Warm & Amber $24.54, 125 ml ($19.63 per 100 ml)
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Extreme (same house) 87% (402) spicy 27 people Gourmand / Coffee $89, 90 ml ($98.89 per 100 ml)
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Illicit Green (same house) 85% (331) sweet and gourmand 40% long · 35% moderate (69) Gourmand $105, 75 ml ($140 per 100 ml)
Women Secret Gold Seduction 83% (112) sweet and floral no reports yet Gourmand $28.90, 100 ml
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Nuit Blanche (same house) 80% (680) sweet, gourmand and floral 40% long · 35% moderate (50) Gourmand $72.45, 100 ml
V Canto Lucrethia 79% (394) sweet, gourmand and floral 24 people Floral $153.52, 100 ml
La Rive Touch of Woman 76% (442) sweet, gourmand and floral 45% short · 30% moderate (46) Gourmand $17.38, 90 ml ($19.31 per 100 ml)
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Wild Edition (same house) 75% (130) sweet, gourmand and floral no reports yet Warm & Amber $96, 50 ml ($192 per 100 ml)
Britney Spears Prerogative 69% (484) sweet, gourmand and creamy 45% short · 35% moderate (36) Gourmand about $24, size not listed
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Neon (same house) 68% (257) sweet 40% long · 30% moderate (57) Gourmand $61.99, 30 ml ($206.63 per 100 ml)
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Floral Shock (same house) 64% (177) sweet and floral 40% moderate · 30% long (33) Floral $65.02, 50 ml ($130.04 per 100 ml)

In the Lasts column, "40% long (69)" means that of the 69 people who described it, 40% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.

Six of the 12 with a bottle size on record cost less per ml than Black Opium. Prices change often; an 'about' price is an estimate.

Which fragrance on this list fits you best?

Every pick here comes from votes, wear shares, prices or what people say about seasons.

The matches, one at a time

From Gardenia (94% alike) down to Lucrethia (79%), what each one changes. The table has every pair.

Zara Gardenia

94% of 417 voters say the two smell alike. The overlap is orange blossom in the opening, coffee in the heart and vanilla in the drydown.

Dossier Ambery Vanilla

In the opening, pear and licorice take the place of orange blossom, though both keep pink pepper in the opening and vanilla and patchouli in the drydown.

Police To Be Born To Shine Woman

It leans warm and amber rather than gourmand. In the opening, it lists cinnamon and mandarin orange rather than orange blossom and pink pepper. Both list coffee and jasmine in the heart and vanilla in the drydown.

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Extreme

The clearest note gap is in the opening: cacao rather than pink pepper. Both have jasmine in the heart and vanilla and patchouli in the drydown.

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Illicit Green

On wear, 40% of 69 people say it lasts a long time, against 70% of 787 for Black Opium. They meet on vanilla and patchouli in the drydown. In the opening, expect green mandarin orange and fig leaf in place of pink pepper. One reviewer puts it this way: "It smells very similar to the original Black Opium but creamier."

Women Secret Gold Seduction

The heart is where it parts ways: white blossoms and peach instead of coffee. The overlap is jasmine in the heart and vanilla and patchouli in the drydown.

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Nuit Blanche

It alone lists rice steam in the opening. Both list vanilla in the drydown and pink pepper in the opening. From a review: "It smells like a lighter version of the original Black Opium."

V Canto Lucrethia

It leans floral rather than gourmand. Both have pink pepper in the opening and coffee and jasmine in the heart. Its list also has honeysuckle in the drydown.

Early reads, closest first

Fewer than 100 people have voted on these pairs, so read them as leads.

Early read % who say it smells alike (voters) Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Missguided Babe Night 96% (57) Floral $23.32, 80 ml ($29.15 per 100 ml)
Jeanne Arthes Balade à Paris Soirée Rooftop 95% (55) Gourmand $49.82, 100 ml
Maison Alhambra Opera Noir 94% (90) Gourmand about $30, size not listed

Eight more early reads, with fewer votes and under 94% alike, left out of the table.

How to read these numbers

Each percentage is how many of the people who voted on that pair said the two smell alike. The voter count sits next to it, and anything under 100 voters is flagged as an early read. Nothing below 60% or 30 voters is listed. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

Questions people ask

Quick answers to what people ask about these alternatives, using the votes and prices above.

What smells closest to Black Opium?

Zara Gardenia. 94% of the 417 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the closest of the pairs with 100+ voters. Missguided Babe Night scores higher, 96% of 57, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.

Which Black Opium alternative costs least per ml?

La Rive Touch of Woman, at $19.31 per 100 ml ($17.38, 90 ml). 76% of 442 people say it smells alike.

Which alternative has the highest share saying it lasts a long time?

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Illicit Green, Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Nuit Blanche and Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Neon: 40% of the people who described each say they last a long time (69 for Black Opium Illicit Green, 50 for Black Opium Nuit Blanche, 57 for Black Opium Neon), the highest share among the six alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.

How many alternatives do people back?

13 have 100 or more voters and 11 more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 24 in all. A match needs 60% or more of its voters saying it smells alike to be listed.

Which match has the most voters?

Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium Nuit Blanche: 680 people voted, and 80% of them say it smells alike.

Which alternatives are in the same scent family?

Black Opium sits in the gourmand family. Nine of the 13 in the table share it: Gardenia, Ambery Vanilla, Black Opium Extreme and six others in the table.

In short: 94% of 417 people say Gardenia smells like Black Opium, and it costs less per ml.

Keep exploring: Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium · More from Yves Saint Laurent · All Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium versions compared · Yves Saint Laurent perfumes ranked by people · Browse gourmand perfumes · Orange blossom perfumes. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will shortlist the best fits from this list.

Back to blog