Bottles of Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille and Phaedon Tabac Rouge

Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille vs Phaedon Tabac Rouge: How Alike Are They?

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille vs Phaedon Tabac Rouge: how they compare

In the Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille vs Phaedon Tabac Rouge vote, 74% of 1,097 people say the two smell alike. Tobacco Vanille is filed under Gourmand and Tabac Rouge under Warm & Amber. Still, both lean sweet, spicy and smoky. 90% of 1,438 people say Tobacco Vanille lasts a long time, against 80% of 120 for Tabac Rouge.

Quick facts

The numbers side by side

Compared Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille Phaedon Tabac Rouge
Scent family Gourmand Warm & Amber
Top accords sweet, spicy, gourmand and smoky sweet, spicy, smoky and warm & amber
Lasts 90% long (1,438) 80% long (120)
Projects 85% strong (1,374) 70% strong (91)
Listed price about $445 about $105
Listed seasons fall and winter fall and winter
People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) 4,812 48

In the Lasts and Projects cells, "90% long (1,438)" means that of the 1,438 people who described it, 90% say it lasts a long time.

How are Tobacco Vanille and Tabac Rouge alike?

They share three of the accords in the table: sweet, spicy and smoky. Scendira describes Tobacco Vanille as smoky vanilla tobacco, cocoa dust and dried fruit; Tabac Rouge, as sweet honeyed tobacco, cinnamon smoke, warm resin.

What sets the Tobacco Vanille and Tabac Rouge fragrances apart?

Only Tobacco Vanille lists tobacco leaf, vanilla and cacao; only Tabac Rouge lists honey, cinnamon and benzoin. In the accords, Tobacco Vanille adds gourmand while Tabac Rouge adds warm & amber. A larger share of people say Tobacco Vanille projects strongly (85% of 1,374 against 70% of 91).

Questions and answers

Common questions about this pair, each answered from this page's own data.

Do Tobacco Vanille and Tabac Rouge smell the same?

Not the same, but similar for many people: 74% of 1,097 voters say they smell alike.

Which of the two has better longevity?

A larger share of people say Tobacco Vanille lasts a long time: 90% of 1,438, against 80% of 120 for the other.

Which of the two do more people talk about?

Tobacco Vanille: 4,812 people discuss it in posts, against 48 for the other.

What do the two have in common?

They share three accords (sweet, spicy and smoky).

Are they in the same scent family?

No. Tobacco Vanille is filed under Gourmand, Tabac Rouge under Warm & Amber.

What the percentages mean

% alike is the share of the 1,097 people who voted on this pair who said the two smell alike. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

In short: 74% of 1,097 people say Tobacco Vanille smells like Tabac Rouge.

Keep exploring: Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille · Phaedon Tabac Rouge · Perfumes like Tobacco Vanille · More from Tom Ford · Gourmand perfumes. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will suggest what to try next.

Back to blog