Bottles of Yves Saint Laurent Y and Lattafa Fakhar Black

Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum vs Lattafa Fakhar Black: How Alike Are They?

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum vs Lattafa Fakhar Black: how they compare

On Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum vs Lattafa Fakhar Black, 86% of 2,090 people say the two smell alike. Y Eau de Parfum is filed under Gourmand and Fakhar Black under Warm & Amber. Fakhar Black costs less per ml: $24.95 per 100 ml against $167.21.

In numbers

The two at a glance

Compared Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum Lattafa Fakhar Black
Scent family Gourmand Warm & Amber
Top accords fresh, sweet, fruity and aquatic aromatic, fresh spicy and woody
Lasts 60% long (937) 50% short (192)
Projects 45% strong · 40% moderate (886) 35% moderate · 35% close to skin (58)
Listed price $163.87 (98 ml) $24.95 (100 ml)
Price per 100 ml $167.21 $24.95
Listed seasons spring, summer, fall and winter spring, summer and fall
People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) 1,863 1,069

In the Lasts and Projects cells, "60% long (937)" means that of the 937 people who described it, 60% say it lasts a long time.

What do Y Eau de Parfum and Fakhar Black share?

Their listed notes overlap on nine notes, including apple, bergamot, ginger, juniper berry and lavender. Scendira describes Y Eau de Parfum as cool citrus apple with crisp ginger breeze; Fakhar Black, as crisp apple and ginger with herbal sage and warm cedarwood.

What sets the Y Eau de Parfum and Fakhar Black fragrances apart?

Notes you get in one but not the other: aldehydes, elemi resin and frankincense in Y Eau de Parfum, cedarwood and amberwood in Fakhar Black. In the accords, Y Eau de Parfum adds sweet, fruity and aquatic while Fakhar Black adds aromatic and woody.

Price per 100 ml

Fakhar Black costs less per ml: $24.95 per 100 ml against $167.21. Per ml, Y Eau de Parfum costs 6.7 times as much.

Questions and answers

The usual questions about these two, answered from the same votes, wear shares and prices.

Do Y Eau de Parfum and Fakhar Black smell the same?

86% of 2,090 people say they smell alike, so most find them close rather than the same.

Which one is listed for winter?

Y Eau de Parfum. It is listed for spring, summer, fall and winter; Fakhar Black is listed for spring, summer and fall.

Which of the two do more people talk about?

Y Eau de Parfum: 1,863 people discuss it in posts, against 1,069 for the other.

What do the two have in common?

They share 9 listed notes, including apple, bergamot, ginger, juniper berry and lavender.

Are they in the same scent family?

No. Y Eau de Parfum is filed under Gourmand, Fakhar Black under Warm & Amber.

How we count this

2,090 people voted on this pair, and 86% said the two smell alike. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

In short: 86% of 2,090 people say they smell alike, and Fakhar Black costs less per ml.

Where to go from here: Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum · Lattafa Fakhar Black · Alternatives to Y Eau de Parfum · Alternatives to Fakhar Black · More from Yves Saint Laurent · More from Lattafa. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will suggest what to try next.

Back to blog