Bottles of By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad and Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba

By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad vs Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad vs Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba: how close they are

When it comes to By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad vs Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba, 83% of 1,022 people say the two smell alike. Both lean floral, sweet and fruity. Their listed notes overlap on osmanthus absolute, May Rose absolute, tuberose absolute, jasmine and narcissus.

In numbers

Head to head

Compared By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba
Scent family Floral Floral
Top accords floral, sweet, fruity and fresh floral, powdery, sweet and fruity
Lasts 40% long · 30% moderate (170) 24 people
Projects 45% close to skin · 30% strong (151) 25 people
Listed price $228.96 (50 ml) about $172
Listed seasons spring, summer and fall spring, summer, fall and winter

In the Lasts and Projects cells, "40% long (170)" means that of the 170 people who described it, 40% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.

How are Good Girl Gone Bad and The Queen of Sheba alike?

They share three of the accords in the table: floral, sweet and fruity. In the notes, they meet on osmanthus absolute, May Rose absolute, tuberose absolute, jasmine and narcissus. Scendira describes Good Girl Gone Bad as powdery white florals, creamy amber warmth; The Queen of Sheba, as fresh jasmine and rose, soft powdery cream.

Where do the Good Girl Gone Bad and The Queen of Sheba fragrances differ?

Good Girl Gone Bad adds orange blossom, white cedar and amber, and The Queen of Sheba adds vetiver and cedarwood. In the accords, Good Girl Gone Bad adds fresh while The Queen of Sheba adds powdery.

Questions people ask

What people ask most when choosing between these two, answered from the data above.

Is Good Girl Gone Bad the same as The Queen of Sheba?

Close, not the same: 83% of the 1,022 people who voted call them alike.

Which one is listed for winter?

The Queen of Sheba. It is listed for spring, summer, fall and winter; Good Girl Gone Bad is listed for spring, summer and fall.

What do the two have in common?

They share three accords (floral, sweet and fruity) and five listed notes (osmanthus absolute, May Rose absolute, tuberose absolute, jasmine and narcissus).

How do they compare on wear?

For Good Girl Gone Bad, 40% of 170 people say it lasts a long time and 30% say it lasts a moderate time; 45% of 151 people say it stays close to the skin and 30% say it projects strongly. The Queen of Sheba has 24 people describing how long it lasts so far, too few for a share.

Are they in the same scent family?

Yes, both are filed under Floral.

About the data

1,022 people voted on this pair, and 83% said the two smell alike. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

In short: 83% of 1,022 people say Good Girl Gone Bad smells like The Queen of Sheba.

Keep exploring: By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad · Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba · Alternatives to Good Girl Gone Bad · More from By Kilian · More from Attar Collection. Share two perfumes you love with Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, and it will suggest the next ones to try.

Back to blog