Bottles of By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad, Gritti Adèle, Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women, Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba and Molinard Osmanthus

8 Perfumes Like By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad, Ranked by Voter Agreement

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Perfumes like By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad, ranked by votes

Perfumes like By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad: the best-voted alternative is Gritti Adèle, and 86% of 444 people say the two smell alike. Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women ties at 86% with fewer voters. Adèle costs less per ml: $137 per 100 ml against $457.92. Five pairs have 100+ voters, plus three early reads with 30 to 99 voters.

Quick facts

  • Closest match: Gritti Adèle, which 86% of 444 people say smells alike.
  • 5 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
  • The original itself: 40% of 170 people say it lasts a long time.
  • Same house as the original: By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme.

What does By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad smell like, and who is it for?

By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad, in a line: powdery white florals, creamy amber warmth. By its listed notes, it opens on osmanthus absolute, May Rose absolute and orange blossom; the heart is tuberose absolute, jasmine and narcissus; it dries down to white cedar and amber. The main accords are floral, sweet, fruity, fresh, woody and powdery, in the floral family. Of the 170 people who described how long it lasts, 40% say it lasts a long time and 30% say it lasts a moderate time. It came out in 2012 and carries a women's label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring, summer and fall. In posts about it, 24 people bring up summer or hot weather and 10 bring up weddings. See the full notes on the By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad page.

Side by side: the five perfumes people match to it

Perfume % who say it smells alike (voters) Shared accords Lasts Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Gritti Adèle 86% (444) floral, sweet and fruity 13 people Floral $137, 100 ml
Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women 86% (284) floral and fruity 11 people Floral / White Floral $24.14, 30 ml ($80.47 per 100 ml)
Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba 83% (1,022) floral, sweet and fruity 24 people Floral about $172, size not listed
Molinard Osmanthus Eau de Parfum 78% (370) floral, sweet and fruity 35% long · 35% short (31) Floral $86.06, 75 ml ($114.75 per 100 ml)
By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme (same house) 74% (444) floral and sweet 60% long (41) Floral $239.16, 50 ml ($478.32 per 100 ml)

In the Lasts column, "35% long (31)" means that of the 31 people who described it, 35% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.

Three of the four in the same format with a bottle size on record cost less per ml than Good Girl Gone Bad. Listed prices shift over time; an 'about' price is an estimate.

How do you choose among these fragrances?

A quick way to choose, using counts and prices rather than opinion.

  • Choose Gritti Adèle if you want the closest scent: 86% of 444 people say it smells alike.
  • Choose Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women if price matters most: $80.47 per 100 ml is the lowest among the alternatives with 100+ voters.

What each alternative shares and where it differs

What Adèle, Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme and the rest change, in table order.

Gritti Adèle

Its own addition is tobacco flower in the heart. Both list osmanthus absolute and May Rose absolute in the opening and tuberose absolute in the heart.

Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women

On price, it costs about 18% of Good Girl Gone Bad's price per ml ($80.47 against $457.92 per 100 ml). In the opening, expect apricot in place of osmanthus absolute and orange blossom. Underneath, both have May Rose absolute in the opening and tuberose absolute and narcissus in the heart.

Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba

With 1,022 voters, this is the most-voted pair here, and 83% of them call it alike. They meet on osmanthus absolute and May Rose absolute in the opening and tuberose absolute in the heart. In the drydown, it lists vetiver and cedarwood rather than white cedar and amber. Full comparison.

Molinard Osmanthus Eau de Parfum

It alone lists apricot and iris in the drydown. The overlap is tuberose absolute and jasmine in the heart.

By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme

A larger share of people say it lasts a long time: 60% of 41 people, against 40% of 170 for Good Girl Gone Bad. Both list May Rose absolute and orange blossom in the opening and tuberose absolute in the heart. It adds milk and caramel in the drydown.

Three early reads (30 to 99 voters each, under 86% alike) are left out of the tables: none scores as high as the closest well-voted match.

What the percentages mean

Each percentage is how many of the people who voted on that pair said the two smell alike. The voter count sits next to it, and anything under 100 voters is flagged as an early read. Nothing below 60% or 30 voters is listed. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

FAQ

Quick answers to what people ask about these alternatives, using the votes and prices above.

What smells closest to Good Girl Gone Bad?

Gritti Adèle. 86% of the 444 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, tied with Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women on share; it leads on voters.

Which perfume like Good Girl Gone Bad is lowest per 100 ml?

Maison Alhambra Kismet for Women, at $80.47 per 100 ml ($24.14, 30 ml). 86% of 284 people say it smells alike.

Which alternative has the highest share saying it lasts a long time?

By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme: 60% of the 41 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the two alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.

How many perfumes smell like Good Girl Gone Bad?

Five have 100 or more voters and three more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 8 in all. Only pairs where at least 60% of voters say they smell alike make the list.

Which match has the most voters?

Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba: 1,022 people voted, and 83% of them say it smells alike.

Which alternatives are in the same scent family?

Good Girl Gone Bad sits in the floral family. All five alternatives in the table are in the same family.

In short: 86% of 444 people say Adèle smells like Good Girl Gone Bad, and it costs less per ml.

Where next: By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad · More from By Kilian · By Kilian perfumes ranked by people · Good Girl Gone Bad vs The Queen of Sheba · Browse floral perfumes. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will shortlist the best fits from this list.

Back to blog