Bottles of Creed Silver Mountain Water and Casamorati 1888 Mefisto

Creed Silver Mountain Water vs Casamorati 1888 Mefisto: How Alike Are They?

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Creed Silver Mountain Water vs Casamorati 1888 Mefisto: how close they are

On Creed Silver Mountain Water vs Casamorati 1888 Mefisto, 80% of 1,373 people say the two smell alike. Both lean fresh and citrus. Their listed notes overlap on bergamot, musk and sandalwood. Below: what they share, where they differ and what each costs.

At a glance

The numbers side by side

Compared Creed Silver Mountain Water Casamorati 1888 Mefisto
Scent family Fresh Fresh
Top accords fresh, citrus, aquatic and fruity citrus, fresh, floral and green
Lasts 50% short (543) 50% long (368)
Projects 55% close to skin (416) 50% moderate (345)
Listed price $318 (100 ml) $330 (100 ml)
Listed seasons spring and summer spring and summer
People discussing it (all posts, not the vote) 1,298 13

In the Lasts and Projects cells, "50% short (543)" means that of the 543 people who described it, 50% say it fades quickly.

How are Silver Mountain Water and Mefisto alike?

They share two of the accords in the table: fresh and citrus. Their listed notes overlap on bergamot, musk and sandalwood. In a line each: Silver Mountain Water is cool mountain air, citrus berries, clean musk; Mefisto is bright grapefruit and bergamot over clean musk.

Where do the Silver Mountain Water and Mefisto fragrances differ?

Silver Mountain Water adds galbanum, blackcurrant and orange, and Mefisto adds grapefruit, lavender and Calabrian lemon. In the accords, Silver Mountain Water adds aquatic and fruity while Mefisto adds floral and green.

What each costs

Both list at about the same price for the same 100 ml bottle ($318 and $330).

Questions people ask

Common questions about this pair, each answered from this page's own data.

Is Silver Mountain Water the same as Mefisto?

Not the same, but close for most people: 80% of 1,373 voters say they smell alike.

Which of the two do more people talk about?

Silver Mountain Water: 1,298 people discuss it in posts, against 13 for the other.

What do the two have in common?

They share two accords (fresh and citrus) and three listed notes (bergamot, musk and sandalwood).

How do they compare on wear?

For Silver Mountain Water, 50% of 543 people say it fades quickly; 55% of 416 people say it stays close to the skin. For Mefisto, 50% of 368 people say it lasts a long time; 50% of 345 people say it projects moderately.

Are they in the same scent family?

Yes, both are filed under Fresh.

What the percentages mean

The 80% figure comes from people voting on whether these two smell alike; 1,373 voted. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

In short: 80% of 1,373 people say Silver Mountain Water smells like Mefisto.

Next steps: Creed Silver Mountain Water · Casamorati 1888 Mefisto · Perfumes like Silver Mountain Water · More from Creed · More from Casamorati 1888. Still torn? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you already love, and it will point you to the ones worth sampling.

Back to blog