Bottles of Creed Silver Mountain Water, Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage, Ajmal Silver Shade, Afnan Supremacy In Heaven and Banana Republic Metal Rain

26 Perfumes Like Creed Silver Mountain Water, Ranked by Voter Agreement

By Amrita Kriplani, founder

Perfumes like Creed Silver Mountain Water, closest first

Perfumes like Creed Silver Mountain Water: among pairs with 100 or more voters, the one people match most closely is Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage, and 91% of 1,543 people say the two smell alike. Club de Nuit Sillage costs less per ml: $27.15 per 100 ml against $318.

At a glance

  • Closest match: Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage, which 91% of 1,543 people say smells alike.
  • 15 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
  • Sharing its fresh family: 9 of the 15.

How does Creed Silver Mountain Water smell, and who wears it?

Creed Silver Mountain Water in brief: cool mountain air, citrus berries, clean musk. By its listed notes, it opens on bergamot, galbanum, blackcurrant and orange; the heart is ozonic notes and tea; it dries down to musk and sandalwood. The main accords are fresh, citrus, aquatic, fruity, green and woody, which puts it with the fresh perfumes. Of the 543 people who described how long it lasts, 50% say it fades quickly. Of the 416 people who described how far it projects, 55% say it stays close to the skin. It lists at $318 for 100 ml. It came out in 1995 and carries a unisex label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring and summer. In posts about it, 250 people bring up summer or hot weather, 111 bring up winter or cold weather and 102 bring up work or the office. See the full notes on the Creed Silver Mountain Water page.

The 15 closest matches, in one table

Perfume % who say it smells alike (voters) Shared accords Lasts Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage 91% (1,543) fresh, citrus and aquatic 75% long (465) Fresh / Citrus $28.78, 106 ml ($27.15 per 100 ml)
Ajmal Silver Shade 87% (240) fresh and citrus 22 people Floral $29.99, 100 ml
Afnan Supremacy In Heaven 86% (375) fresh, citrus and aquatic 45% long · 35% moderate (108) Fresh / Citrus $25, 100 ml
Banana Republic Metal Rain 84% (124) fresh, citrus and green 65% short (35) Fresh $28.87, 75 ml ($38.49 per 100 ml)
Al Haramain L'Aventure Blanche 83% (181) fresh and fruity 26 people Floral $33.90, 100 ml
Armaf Derby Club House Blanche 82% (338) fresh and green 55% short (47) Fresh $22.34, 100 ml
Al Rehab Silver 81% (843) fresh and citrus 45% moderate · 30% short (81) Fresh about $10, size not listed
Rasasi Al Wisam Day 81% (638) fresh and woody 65% long (73) Floral $33.32, 100 ml
Casamorati 1888 Mefisto 80% (1,373) fresh, citrus and aquatic 50% long (368) Fresh / Citrus $330, 100 ml
Franck Olivier Sun Java White Men 79% (122) fresh and citrus 50% moderate (35) Gourmand $34, 75 ml ($45.33 per 100 ml)
Casamorati 1888 Mefisto Gentiluomo 78% (350) fresh and citrus 60% long (249) Fresh $315, 100 ml
Bond No. 9 Hamptons 71% (334) fresh, citrus and aquatic 29 people Fresh $450, 100 ml
Montale Boise Fruite 71% (330) fresh, fruity and woody 20 people Fruity $76.29, 100 ml
Rasasi Entebaa 70% (125) fruity and woody 50% long (92) Gourmand $21.84, 100 ml
Calvin Klein CK One Essence 68% (133) fresh, citrus and green 45% moderate · 30% short (62) Fresh $73, 50 ml ($146 per 100 ml)

In the Lasts column, "75% long (465)" means that of the 465 people who described it, 75% say it lasts a long time; under 30 people we show the count only.

12 of the 14 with a bottle size on record cost less per ml than Silver Mountain Water. Listed prices shift over time; an 'about' price is an estimate.

Which fragrance on this list fits you best?

These picks follow the numbers, so read them as starting points, not verdicts.

  • Choose Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage if you want the closest scent: 91% of 1,543 people say it smells alike.
  • Choose Rasasi Entebaa if price matters most: $21.84 per 100 ml is the lowest among the alternatives with 100+ voters.
  • Choose Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage if you want more projection: 70% of 421 people say it projects strongly, the highest share here.
  • Skip Ajmal Silver Shade if you want to stay in the fresh family: it is filed under floral.

How each one compares

Eight write-ups, Club de Nuit Sillage first, each naming what that perfume adds or drops. The table has every pair.

Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage

The clearest note gap is in the opening: lemon and ginger rather than galbanum and orange. Both list bergamot and blackcurrant in the opening and musk in the drydown. Read the full comparison.

Ajmal Silver Shade

It leans floral rather than fresh. It adds lime and lemon in the opening. Underneath, both have bergamot and blackcurrant in the opening and musk in the drydown.

Afnan Supremacy In Heaven

Its own addition is woody notes in the drydown. They meet on bergamot and blackcurrant in the opening and tea in the heart.

Banana Republic Metal Rain

In the opening, it swaps bergamot and orange for lemon and basil. The overlap is blackcurrant in the opening, tea in the heart and musk in the drydown.

Al Haramain L'Aventure Blanche

It's floral, where Silver Mountain Water is fresh. Both list bergamot in the opening and sandalwood in the drydown. Its list also has rose and lemon in the opening.

Armaf Derby Club House Blanche

82% of 338 voters say the two smell alike. Both have bergamot and orange in the opening and tea in the heart. Of the 47 people who described how long it lasts, 55% say it fades quickly.

Al Rehab Silver

It is called alike by 81% of the 843 people who voted on the pair. What it adds is citrus in the opening. They share fresh and citrus accords. Of the 81 people who described how long it lasts, 45% say it lasts a moderate time and 30% say it fades quickly.

Rasasi Al Wisam Day

Its own addition is oakmoss and oud in the drydown. They meet on bergamot in the opening and musk in the drydown.

Smaller samples so far (early reads)

These have 30 to 99 voters each, so the votes are still small.

Early read % who say it smells alike (voters) Scent family Price (per 100 ml)
Riiffs Privè Platinum Silver 94% (62) Woody $20.30, 100 ml
Al Haramain L'Aventure Fraîche 91% (43) Fresh / Citrus $36.26, 100 ml
M.INT Neon Night 91% (35) Floral $212, 70 ml ($302.86 per 100 ml)

Eight more early reads, with fewer votes and under 91% alike, left out of the table.

How we count this

Voters are the people who rated each pair; % alike is the part of them who said the two smell alike. Pairs need 60%+ agreement and 30+ votes to appear here, with under-100-vote pairs marked as early reads. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.

Common questions

Common questions about these alternatives, each answered from this page's own numbers.

Which perfume smells most like Silver Mountain Water?

Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage. 91% of the 1,543 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the closest of the pairs with 100+ voters. Riiffs Privè Platinum Silver scores higher, 94% of 62, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.

Which Silver Mountain Water alternative costs least per ml?

Riiffs Privè Platinum Silver, at $20.30 for 100 ml. 94% of 62 people say it smells alike. It is an early read (under 100 voters). Al Rehab Silver lists lower, at about $10, but no bottle size is on record, so it can't be put per 100 ml.

Which of these do people most often say lasts a long time?

Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage: 75% of the 465 people who described it say it lasts a long time, the highest share among the 11 alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.

How many alternatives are listed here?

15 have 100 or more voters and 11 more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 26 in all. A match needs 60% or more of its voters saying it smells alike to be listed.

Do the alternatives share its scent family?

Silver Mountain Water sits in the fresh family. Nine of the 15 in the table share it: Club de Nuit Sillage, Supremacy In Heaven, Metal Rain and six others in the table.

Are any alternatives from the same house?

No. Every alternative listed here comes from a house other than Creed.

In short: 91% of 1,543 people say Club de Nuit Sillage smells like Silver Mountain Water, and it costs less per ml.

Next steps: Creed Silver Mountain Water · More from Creed · Best Creed perfumes, ranked · Silver Mountain Water vs Club de Nuit Sillage · Silver Mountain Water vs Mefisto. Still torn? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you already love, and it will narrow this list to the ones worth sampling.

Back to blog