Perfumes Like Carolina Herrera Good Girl: 25 Alternatives People Say Smell Alike
By Amrita Kriplani, founderShare
Perfumes like Carolina Herrera Good Girl, closest first
Among perfumes like Carolina Herrera Good Girl with 100+ voters on the pair, the closest match is Lattafa Qimmah for Women, and 91% of 434 people say the two smell alike. The trade-off is wear: 35% of 49 people say Qimmah for Women lasts a long time, against 65% of 338 for Good Girl.
Key facts
- Closest match: Lattafa Qimmah for Women, which 91% of 434 people say smells alike.
- 10 alternatives have 100 or more voters each.
- Sharing its floral family: 5 of the 10.
- Same house as the original: Carolina Herrera Good Girl Légère.
What does Carolina Herrera Good Girl smell like, and when do people wear it?
Scendira describes Carolina Herrera Good Girl as toasty coffee and almond sweetness, soft musky florals. By its listed notes, it opens on almond, bergamot, coffee and lemon; the heart is jasmine sambac, orange blossom, tuberose and praliné; it dries down to roasted tonka bean, amber, cocoa and cashmere. The main accords are sweet, floral, gourmand, creamy, warm & amber and spicy, which puts it with the floral perfumes. Of the 338 people who described how long it lasts, 65% say it lasts a long time. Of the 318 people who described how far it projects, 60% say it projects strongly. It came out in 2016 and carries a women's label, which describes marketing, not who can wear it. Season votes on review sites place it in spring, fall and winter. In posts about it, 140 people bring up summer or hot weather, 106 bring up winter or cold weather and 98 bring up work or the office. See the full notes on the Carolina Herrera Good Girl page.
The well-voted alternatives at a glance
| Perfume | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Shared accords | Lasts | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lattafa Qimmah for Women | 91% (434) | floral | 45% moderate · 35% long (49) | Floral / White Floral | $18.99, 100 ml |
| La Rive Miss Dream | 84% (654) | sweet, floral and creamy | 35% moderate · 35% short (59) | Gourmand | $14.44, 100 ml |
| O Boticário Floratta Red | 82% (663) | sweet and gourmand | no reports yet | Floral | $56, 75 ml ($74.67 per 100 ml) |
| Ard Al Zaafaran Bint Hooran | 80% (205) | sweet, floral and spicy | 35% long · 35% short (35) | Floral | $25.48, 100 ml |
| Shakira Dance Midnight | 76% (144) | sweet, gourmand and spicy | no reports yet | Gourmand | $28.65, 50 ml ($57.30 per 100 ml) |
| Al Haramain Rawaa | 75% (241) | sweet and floral | 24 people | Warm & Amber | $24.44, 100 ml |
| Carolina Herrera Good Girl Légère (same house) | 71% (978) | sweet, floral and warm & amber | no reports yet | Gourmand | about $100, size not listed |
| Zara Deep Garden 2018 | 71% (287) | sweet and floral | 16 people | Floral | $37, 30 ml ($123.33 per 100 ml) |
| Guess Bella Vita | 70% (142) | sweet and floral | 45% moderate · 30% long (30) | Gourmand | $30.84, 100 ml |
| Abercrombie & Fitch Authentic Night Femme | 65% (106) | sweet and floral | 18 people | Floral | $46.79, 100 ml |
In the Lasts column, "45% moderate (49)" means that of the 49 people who described it, 45% say it lasts a moderate time; under 30 people we show the count only.
Prices move often, and an 'about' price is only an estimate.
How do you choose among these fragrances?
Every pick here comes from votes, wear shares, prices or what people say about seasons.
- Choose Lattafa Qimmah for Women if you want the closest scent: 91% of 434 people say it smells alike.
- Choose La Rive Miss Dream if price matters most: $14.44 per 100 ml is the lowest among the alternatives with 100+ voters.
- Skip Shakira Dance Midnight if you want to stay in the floral family: it is filed under gourmand.
The matches, one at a time
Eight write-ups, Qimmah for Women first, each naming what that perfume adds or drops. The table has every pair.
Lattafa Qimmah for Women
In the drydown, it swaps cocoa and cashmere for vanilla and cacao pod. Underneath, they meet on almond and coffee in the opening and jasmine sambac in the heart.
La Rive Miss Dream
It leans gourmand rather than floral. The overlap is bergamot in the opening and jasmine sambac in the heart. In the drydown, expect vanilla in place of cocoa and cashmere.
O Boticário Floratta Red
Its own addition is dark chocolate in the drydown. Both list orange blossom and tuberose in the heart and amber in the drydown.
Ard Al Zaafaran Bint Hooran
35% of 35 people say it lasts a long time, against 65% of 338 for Good Girl. Both have almond and coffee in the opening and jasmine sambac in the heart. In the drydown, it lists vanilla rather than cocoa.
Shakira Dance Midnight
It's gourmand, where Good Girl is floral. They meet on bergamot in the opening and jasmine sambac and tuberose in the heart. It brings in vanilla in the drydown.
Al Haramain Rawaa
It alone lists iris in the heart. The overlap is almond and coffee in the opening and jasmine sambac in the heart. It leans warm and amber rather than floral.
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Légère
The opening is where it parts ways: Ylang-Ylang and mandarin orange instead of almond and coffee. Both list bergamot and lemon in the opening and jasmine sambac in the heart. Read the full comparison.
Zara Deep Garden 2018
71% of 287 voters say the two smell alike. Its own addition is pear in the opening. Both have tuberose in the heart.
Early reads (30 to 99 voters)
Fewer than 100 people have voted on these pairs, so read them as leads.
| Early read | % who say it smells alike (voters) | Scent family | Price (per 100 ml) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maison Alhambra B.A.D. Femme | 97% (92) | Floral | $20, 100 ml |
| Dossier Fruity Almond | 97% (62) | Floral | $28.94, 50 ml ($57.88 per 100 ml) |
13 more early reads, with fewer votes and under 91% alike, left out of the table.
How we count this
Voters are the people who rated each pair; % alike is the part of them who said the two smell alike. Pairs need 60%+ agreement and 30+ votes to appear here, with under-100-vote pairs marked as early reads. The votes come from the Scendira Scent Index, which pools what people say across reviews and forums; data as of 15 Nov 2026.
Questions and answers
What shoppers tend to ask next, answered from the votes and listings above.
What is the closest match to Good Girl?
Lattafa Qimmah for Women. 91% of the 434 people who voted on the pair say the two smell alike, the best vote among pairs with 100+ voters. Maison Alhambra B.A.D. Femme scores higher, 97% of 92, but that is an early read with fewer than 100 voters.
Which perfume like Good Girl is lowest per 100 ml?
La Rive Miss Dream, at $14.44 for 100 ml. 84% of 654 people say it smells alike.
Which alternative do the most people say lasts a long time?
Lattafa Qimmah for Women and Ard Al Zaafaran Bint Hooran: 35% of the people who described each say they last a long time (49 for Qimmah for Women, 35 for Bint Hooran), the highest share among the four alternatives in the table with 30 or more people describing wear.
How many perfumes smell like Good Girl?
Ten have 100 or more voters and 15 more are early reads with 30 to 99 voters, 25 in all. A pair is listed only when 60% or more of its voters say it smells alike.
Which alternative has the most votes?
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Légère: 978 people voted, and 71% of them say it smells alike.
Do the alternatives share its scent family?
Good Girl sits in the floral family. Five of the ten in the table share it: Qimmah for Women, Floratta Red, Bint Hooran, Deep Garden 2018 and Authentic Night Femme.
In short: 91% of 434 people say Qimmah for Women smells like Good Girl.
See also: Carolina Herrera Good Girl · More from Carolina Herrera · The Carolina Herrera Good Girl line, version by version · Carolina Herrera perfumes ranked by people · Good Girl vs Good Girl Légère. Not sure where to start? Tell Dira, Your Fragrance Finder, two perfumes you love, and it will shortlist the best fits from this list.